Updated College Basketball Player of the Year Award Odds: Carey Jr Favored, But Winston Coming on Strong

  • Duke freshman Vernon Carey Jr. is the slight favorite to win the AP’s College Basketball Player of the Year
  • Michigan State senior Cassius Winston (+400) is starting to heat up after suffering an early-season tragedy
  • Louisville forward Jordan Nwora (+650) struggled in a recent matchup with rival Kansas

Zion Williamson was a near-unanimous choice (59 of 64 votes) for the Associated Press Player of the Year in 2018-19.

But at the midway mark of the 2019-20 season, the field is considerably more crowded. Let’s check the latest odds at BetOnline and determine what players we should keep an eye on in the second half.


Player (Team) Odds
Vernon Carey Jr. (Duke) +350
Cassius Winston (Michigan State) +400
Jordan Nwora (Louisville) +650
Obi Toppin (Dayton) +700
Devon Dotson (Kansas) +900
Markus Howard (Marquette) +900
Peyton Pritchard (Oregon) +900
Kaleb Wesson (Ohio State) +1000
Myles Powell (Seton Hall) +1000
Filip Petrusev (Gonzaga) +1200
Luka Garza (Iowa) +1200
Malachi Flynn (San Diego State) +1200


With 7-foot-1 center James Wiseman out of college basketball, the NCAA’s best big-man is Duke freshman Vernon Carey Jr.

The 6-foot-10 son of a former Miami Hurricanes offensive lineman torched his dad’s alma mater on Saturday with a game-high 24 points in a 95-62 win.

Looking like a future top-five pick, Carey Jr. is averaging 18.4 points, 9.0 rebounds and 2.1 blocks through his first 14 games while shooting over 62 per cent from the field.

With the No. 2 Blue Devils ranked second in the latest AP poll, Carey Jr. will only get more national media exposure as the season wears on. He may not have the perimeter game to dominate in the modern NBA, but he’s simply too big and too strong for most fives at the college level.


Cassius Winston’s decision to return to Michigan State for his senior season vaulted the Spartans to No. 1 in everybody’s preseason rankings.

However, Tom Izzo’s club disappointed early in the season and Winston tragically lost his younger brother Zachary to suicide about six weeks ago.

The 6-foot-1 point guard has courageously played through the pain, averaging 18.9 points and 6.3 assists through 14 games. He also poured in a career-high 32 points against No. 19 Michigan on Sunday.

It’s impossible not to root for Winston given the circumstances, and voters are likely to feel the same way if the No. 8 Spartans can play their way back into the national title conversation.


Jordan Nwora (+650) is averaging a career-high 21 points in his junior season, but the Louisville forward struggled in a spotlight game against rival Kentucky before the New Year, going 2-of-10 from the field with three turnovers in a 78-70 overtime-loss.

The Athletic named Obi Toppin (+700) their midseason national player of the year. The Dayton Flyers’ dunking machine has put up 19.5 points per game while shooting 62.7 percent from the field.

Duke sophomore guard Tre Jones is putting up 14.2 and 7.2 assists per game, but is not listed on the board above (perhaps due to missing two games with a sprained ankle).

Some other notable omissions include Udoka Azubuike, whose 17 points and 11 boards led No. 3 Kansas to a 60-53 win over No. 16 West Virginia on Saturday, and Penn State’s Lamar Stevens.

Averaging 16.4 points and 7.0 rebounds, the senior forward is helping put the 12-2 Nittany Lions on the college basketball map.

Pick: Cassius Winston (+400)

Steve Starr

Steve is one of the many Americans who spends Sunday watching football on the couch and gorging on heart-clogging eats. He describes himself as a good father, great dog owner, and mediocre gambler and husband.

Learn to bet on sports today Here!