Caleb Williams Favored For Heisman Trophy Repeat in 2023

  • USC’s Caleb Williams and North Carolina’s Drake Maye are the early Heisman Trophy favorites
  • Quarterbacks have captured six of the last seven awards, as well as 11 of the past 13.
  • Marvin Harrison Jr. (+5000) is viewed a longshot to be named the most outstanding player in college football

Caleb Williams is expected to go No. 1 overall in the 2024 NFL Draft after capturing the Heisman in his sophomore season. But first, he’ll try to accomplish something no one else has in almost a half century – a Heisman repeat.

Can the Trojan star pull it off? Before we examine the early Heisman Trophy Betting Odds, be sure to check out our guide to betting on the 2023-24 NCAAF National Championship.

2023 Heisman Trophy Winner

PlayerBetOnline Review
Caleb Williams+550
Drake Maye+600
Jordan Travis+800
Michael Penix Jr.+1200
Sam Hartman+1200
Bo Nix+1400
Jayden Daniels+2000
Joe Milton+2000
Kyle McCord+2000
Cade Klubnik+2200
Drew Allar+2500
Quinn Ewers+2500
Brock Vandagriff+2800
Blake Corum+3300
Carson Beck+4000
Dillon Gabriel+4000
J.J. McCarthy+4000
Spencer Rattler+4000
Ty Simpson+4000
DJ Uiagalelei+5000
Marvin Harrison Jr.+5000

Can Caleb do it again?

Caleb Williams (+550) is favored to win the Heisman Trophy for the second-consecutive year. The USC standout passed for 4,537 yards with 42 touchdowns and only five interceptions in 2022, adding 382 yards and ten scores on the ground. Given that Lincoln Riley has coached three Heisman winners in the past six years (Baker Mayfield and Kyler Murray being the others), it’s hard to see why Williams couldn’t go back to back.

Well, other than a long historical precedent against it. Ohio State RB Archie Griffin is the only college football player ever to repeat, claiming the Heisman in the 1974 and ’75 seasons. Despite putting up big numbers in 2022, Alabama’s Bryce Young wasn’t even a finalist for the award last year. And, after becoming first ever sophomore to win the Heisman, Tim Tebow finished third and fifth in voting in subsequent seasons.

Maye-day, Maye-day!

Drake Maye (+600) led North Carolina to its first ACC Coastal title since 2015, passing for 4,321 yards, 38 touchdowns and seven picks in 2022. The redshirt sophomore is not only a Heisman contender, but a challenger to go No. 1 overall in the 2024 NFL Draft.

However, the ACC Player of the Year will be playing under a new offensive coordinator next season. And, unlike the Trojans, the Tar Heels are unlikely to be in the mix for neither the College Football Playoff nor the National Championship.

Caleb Williams2024 Heisman Winner
Bet now
Drake Maye2024 Heisman Winner
Bet now

Other top QB contenders

The next signal caller on the board is Jordan Travis (+800). The Seminoles senior set a new school record with 468 yards of total offense in a Cheez-It Bowl win over Oklahoma. He could become the first Florida State QB to win the Heisman since Jameis Winston a decade ago.

Michael Penix Jr. (+1200)  led the Power Five in passing yards (4,354) while leading Washington to its best record (11-2) since 2016. Sam Hartman may have been the best QB in the transfer portal but Notre Dame’s new starter is overvalued at +1200. Even sixth-year senior Bo Nix (+1400) has a better shot at the award after reviving his career in Oregon.

Best Bets

Jayden Daniels (+2000) was also the only quarterback in college football to rush for more than 1,000 yards in 2022. The LSU senior is one of the few names on the list with a shot at competing for the National Championship in 2023-24.

Following in the footsteps of Justin Fields and C.J. Stroud, Kyle McCord (+2000) will be at the controls of Ryan Day’s high-powered Ohio State offense. Speaking of which, Marvin Harrison Jr. (+5000) is available at long odds despite being widely regarded as the best WR in college football. The Buckeye had 77 catches for 1,263 yards and 14 TDs in 2022.

Jayden Daniels2024 Heisman Winner
Bet now

See below the top sportsbooks where you can wager online and choose the best one for you:




50% up to $1,000

Bet Now




100% up to $1,000

Bet Now




125% Sports Bonus - up to $2,500

Bet Now
Steve Starr

Steve is the quintessential American sports enthusiast. He has mastered the art of Sundays, devoting them to football, and barbecue parties. He proudly wears the hats of a good father, husband and a great dog owner. Aside from his decades of contributing to different top-tier sports publications, Steve has also found his niche on Twitter, where he publishes funny and relatable sports-related insights. When he's not busy tweeting, Steve loves to watch each game unfold live. He possesses an innate talent for finding humor in the sports world, appreciating both the thrilling moments and the comedic mishaps that make each event unique.